The journey from idealistic recruit to disillusioned veteran represents one of the most profound psychological transformations in modern society. Young men and women join the military with noble aspirations—to serve their country, protect their loved ones, find purpose, and be part of something greater than themselves. Yet many eventually confront a harsh reality: their sacrifice and service often advance interests far removed from their initial motivations. This disconnect between idealistic expectations and the realities of service creates a profound sense of betrayal that can haunt veterans long after their discharge.

The Allure of Military Service and the Targeting of Idealism

Military recruitment deliberately taps into young people’s natural idealism, presenting service as a path to purpose, belonging, and meaning. The British Army’s 2020 recruitment campaign explicitly targeted teenagers who lacked self-confidence, promising that military service would provide “confidence that lasts a lifetime”[2]. This approach is not unique to the UK; militaries worldwide understand that idealism serves as powerful recruitment leverage.

Exploiting Vulnerability and Class Divisions

Modern military recruitment strategies systematically target socioeconomically vulnerable populations. Evidence from a marketing brief for the British Army’s 2017 recruitment campaign explicitly identified their “core regular target audience” as “16-24, primarily C2DE. Mean household income 10K”[7]. The brief also specifically targeted poorer northern cities and Welsh areas for recruitment efforts[7]. This deliberate targeting of economically disadvantaged youth raises serious ethical questions about informed consent and exploitation.

Similarly, in the United States, military recruiters concentrate their efforts in disadvantaged communities where economic opportunities are limited. As recruitment levels have reached crisis points, these tactics have only intensified[9]. The military often represents one of the few available pathways to education, healthcare, and social mobility for many young people from lower socioeconomic backgrounds.

The Appeal to Noble Purpose

What makes military recruitment particularly effective is its appeal to young people’s desire for meaning. A historian’s perspective on extremism notes that while alienation plays a role in youth recruitment, “a misguided sense of idealism often plays a surprisingly important part”[5]. The military taps into this same wellspring of idealism, presenting itself as a noble calling where one can make a difference in the world.

The Transformation: From Idealist to Instrument

Upon entering military service, recruits undergo intensive training designed to transform civilians into soldiers. This process necessarily involves breaking down individual identity and rebuilding it around military values and group cohesion. While this serves legitimate military purposes, it can also function as a form of conditioning that prepares individuals to carry out actions they might otherwise question.

Building Intense Bonds That Replace Other Values

The bonds formed between soldiers during training and especially combat are uniquely powerful. As war correspondent Sebastian Junger observed, “The willingness to die for another person is a form of love that even religions fail to inspire, and the experience of it changes a person profoundly”[18]. These intense connections serve a dual purpose—they foster unit cohesion necessary for military effectiveness while simultaneously creating psychological conditions where loyalty to comrades can override personal moral considerations.

Abuses That Reinforce Obedience

Unfortunately, military units worldwide have long histories of abusive practices that reinforce hierarchical power structures. From the brutal “dedovshchina” hazing system in Russian forces to documented abuses at the UK’s Army Foundation College in Harrogate, these practices can constitute systematic breaking of individual will[6][4]. In the most severe cases, these include sexual assault and exploitation, as documented in reports about military initiation ceremonies[16].

The Bitter Awakening: Recognizing Exploitation

For many service members, disillusionment begins when they confront the disconnect between stated military purposes and operational realities. This awakening typically unfolds gradually as they witness or participate in actions that challenge their moral frameworks.

The Moral Burden of Military Service

Soldiers bear unique moral burdens. As philosophers Michael Robillard and Bradley J. Strawser argue, soldiers are “exploited insofar as they are pressured to shoulder additional moral responsibilities, moral deliberative roles, and moral risks”[12]. These burdens are particularly heavy when the conflicts they participate in lack clear moral justification or when their actions lead to civilian casualties.

The concept of “moral risk”—the risk of committing serious moral wrongdoing—is especially relevant. Military recruitment practices “exacerbate and concentrate moral risk exposure,” particularly when targeting youth from areas of socioeconomic deprivation[17]. Young recruits are rarely equipped to fully comprehend these moral dimensions when they enlist.

Realizing Their Role in Larger Power Structures

Perhaps the most bitter pill for many veterans is realizing that their service primarily advanced state interests, corporate agendas, or geopolitical strategies rather than the noble causes they believed in. This recognition often comes later in their service or even after discharge, as they gain distance and perspective from their experiences.

Recent military misadventures have accelerated this disillusionment. The chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan after twenty years of conflict has undermined public confidence in the US military, with only 60 percent of Americans expressing trust in the institution—the lowest level in two decades[9][1]. For those who served in these conflicts, questioning the purpose of their sacrifice can be devastating.

The Aftermath: Living with Disillusionment

The transition from military to civilian life is challenging under the best circumstances. For those carrying the burden of moral injury and disillusionment, this transition can be especially difficult.

The Search for Meaning After Service

After experiencing the intensity of military life and combat, many veterans struggle to find comparable meaning in civilian life. As war correspondent Sebastian Junger notes, “Perfectly sane, good men have been drawn back to combat over and over again… The defense of the tribe is an insanely compelling idea, and once you’ve been exposed to it, there’s almost nothing else you’d rather do”[18]. This difficulty in finding comparable purpose can exacerbate feelings of alienation and betrayal.

Processing Moral Injury

For veterans who participated in actions they later came to question, moral injury—the psychological damage from performing or witnessing actions that transgress deeply held moral beliefs—can be profound. Unlike post-traumatic stress, which results from fear, moral injury stems from guilt and moral confusion. Veterans must reconcile their actions with their core values, often without adequate support.

The Cyclical Nature of Military Exploitation

What makes this pattern particularly troubling is its cyclical nature. The disillusionment of one generation rarely prevents the idealistic enlistment of the next, as recruitment practices continually evolve to target new cohorts of vulnerable youth.

Persistent Recruiting Despite Known Harms

Despite widespread documentation of the physical and psychological harms associated with military service, recruitment practices continue to downplay these risks while emphasizing benefits. Military recruiters rarely discuss moral injury, the potential for disillusionment, or the complex ethical territory soldiers must navigate[7][2]. The British Army has been accused of “trying to exploit teenagers who lack self-confidence” with misleading recruitment advertising[2].

The Role of Military Glorification

Military recruitment operates within a broader cultural context that often glorifies service while minimizing its complexities and costs. This cultural environment makes it difficult for young people to make fully informed decisions about enlistment and contributes to the cycle of idealism followed by disillusionment.

Conclusion: Breaking the Cycle

The pattern of young people joining military service with good intentions only to become disillusioned by their experiences represents a profound ethical challenge for society. These were indeed good people, driven by genuine idealism, who found themselves serving interests they had not anticipated or consented to when they enlisted.

Addressing this issue requires honesty about military recruitment practices, greater transparency about the realities of service, and broader societal conversations about the purposes for which we deploy military force. It also demands better support for veterans as they process their experiences and reintegrate into civilian society.

Most importantly, we must recognize that the exploitation of young people’s idealism for state and corporate interests represents a profound betrayal of trust—one that damages not only individual lives but also the moral fabric of the societies that permit it to continue. Until we confront this reality directly, new generations of idealistic youth will continue to cycle through the same painful journey of disillusionment and betrayal that has marked so many who came before them.

Citations:
[1] https://en.topwar.ru/224648-zapadnaja-pressa-amerikanskaja-molodezh-razocharovalas-v-voennoj-sluzhbe-i-ne-zhelaet-vstupat-v-rjady-vooruzhennyh-sil-ssha.html
[2] https://www.ppu.org.uk/news/army-preys-vulnerable-teenagers-misleading-new-adverts
[3] https://scholarcommons.sc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4968&context=etd
[4] https://home.crin.org/readlistenwatch/stories/children-in-uniform-a-decade-of-abuse-at-army-foundation-college
[5] https://blog.policy.manchester.ac.uk/featured/2015/07/a-lesson-from-history-the-dangerous-power-of-idealism/
[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dedovshchina
[7] https://www.forceswatch.net/comment/army-recruitment-practices-exploit-and-widen-class-divisions/
[8] https://law-journals-books.vlex.com/vid/state-security-or-exploitation-925682455
[9] https://www.eurasiantimes.com/us-army-engulfed-in-crisis-american-youth-disillusioned-with/
[10] https://warfarehistorynetwork.com/article/the-vermehren-betrayal/
[11] http://www.agediscrimination.info/news/2014/10/8/mod-faces-age-discrimination-fight-over-recruitment-of-16-year-olds
[12] https://stockholmcentre.org/are-soldiers-morally-exploited/
[13] https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/press-release/2019/06/myanmar-bangladesh-older-people-denied-dignity-in-camps-after-facing-military-atrocities-2/
[14] https://www.af.mil/News/Article-Display/Article/3520635/csaf-issues-warning-of-pla-recruitment-of-us-air-force-members-veterans/
[15] https://countercurrents.org/2024/04/global-voices-progressive-idealism-among-students-and-youths-across-borders/
[16] https://www.forward-assist.com/news/2022/3/1/shocking-sex-abuse-of-men-during-military-initiation-ceremonys
[17] http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/120491/3/Parry_filling_the_ranks_published.pdf
[18] https://digitalcommons.odu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1039&context=philosophy_fac_pubs
[19] https://wri-irg.org/en/story/2007/abuse-military-gender-aspects
[20] https://www.reddit.com/r/Veterans/comments/gj1sg8/ive_become_disillusioned/
[21] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3000735/
[22] https://www.parkrecord.com/2025/03/12/a-betrayal-of-the-ideals-we-fought-for/
[23] https://theweek.com/uk-news/60968/britains-child-soldiers-should-the-enlistment-age-be-raised
[24] https://reflections.live/articles/11532/the-grim-reality-young-men-die-for-old-mens-wars-article-by-thangchinlian-guite-15450-lvrxvqlv.html
[25] https://www.aclu.org/publications/soldiers-misfortune-abusive-us-military-recruitment-and-failure-protect-child-soldiers
[26] https://rai.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.0268-540X.2004.00258.x
[27] https://scene-tiger.squarespace.com/s/FINAL-CRIN-Nov22-briefing-harm-and-abuse-child-army-recruits.pdf
[28] https://www.khanacademy.org/humanities/whp-1750/xcabef9ed3fc7da7b:unit-6-world-war-i/xcabef9ed3fc7da7b:6-2-experiences-and-outcomes/a/a-lost-generation-beta
[29] https://home.crin.org/issues/military-enlistment
[30] https://bracingviews.com/2015/06/16/betraying-the-military-and-democracy-by-loving-indifference/
[31] https://home.crin.org/military-recruitment
[32] https://vocal.media/horror/jim-jones-rises-to-power-by-exploiting-idealism-and-faith
[33] https://www.reddit.com/r/TwoXChromosomes/comments/137yhjq/just_a_reminder_to_be_careful_around_military/
[34] https://www.polytechnique-insights.com/en/columns/society/young-people-and-war-a-renewed-patriotism/
[35] https://www.newman.ac.uk/the-soldier-as-victim/
[36] https://press.un.org/en/2016/dsgsm980.doc.htm
[37] https://www.jstor.org/stable/44732766
[38] https://www.nytimes.com/1989/06/07/opinion/l-violence-of-old-men-vs-the-idealism-of-youth-029889.html
[39] https://kb.osu.edu/bitstream/handle/1811/49011/1/Brigade_2506.pdf
[40] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00220027211070574
[41] https://www.redpepper.org.uk/global-politics/war/financial-markets-and-the-military-industrial-complex/
[42] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/00220027211070574
[43] https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-science-review/article/filling-the-ranks-moral-risk-and-the-ethics-of-military-recruitment/AECBBE88736D2AB01470BDB404E537BF
[44] https://www.elgaronline.com/monochap/9781788978514.00012.pdf
[45] https://inequality.org/article/military-recruiters-high-school/
[46] https://shura.shu.ac.uk/28798/8/Owens-ExploitingBullets(AM).pdf
[47] https://committees.parliament.uk/committee/24/defence-committee/news/156892/report-protecting-those-who-protect-us-women-in-the-armed-forces-from-recruitment-to-civilian-life/
[48] https://ideas.repec.org/a/sae/jocore/v66y2022i4-5p729-754.html
[49] https://academic.oup.com/bjc/article/63/5/1309/6858860
[50] https://ti-defence.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/2012-01_MilitaryOwnedBusinesses.pdf
[51] https://sundayguardianlive.com/investigation/pla-exploiting-global-firms-to-recruit-western-military-experts
[52] https://committees.parliament.uk/work/856/women-in-the-armed-forces-from-recruitment-to-civilian-life/news/195323/damning-whistleblower-evidence-reveals-ongoing-sexual-abuse-within-the-armed-services/

---